The following is from changemakers:
MEDIA STATEMENT
June 9 2025.
All Editors
Executive Summary:
The 2025 PNM internal elections will define the party’s future. This position paper by PNM Changemakers 2025 outlines why Marvin Gonzales represents a dangerous step backwards, why Farai Masasai is not yet ready, and why Mayor Chinua Alleyne is the leader most capable of restoring trust, unity, and grounded leadership in the PNM.
From where did he come? Marvin Gonzales is not the future of the PNM – Chinua Alleyne is.
A party at the crossroads
The internal elections of 2025 are more than a leadership contest — they are a referendum on the soul of the People's National Movement. After a sobering general election defeat, the choice before us is stark: do we double down on image, illusion, and entitlement — or do we rebuild with substance, vision, and trust?
Three candidates have stepped forward to lead as chairman. But only one has the grounding, credibility, and temperament to help return the PNM to its rightful place — Mayor Chinua Alleyne.
As Dr. Eric Williams reminded us: "Serve the people — serve the people. That is your motto."
Before we endorse, however, we must call out what must be rejected.
The Illusion of Marvin Gonzales
1. Arrogance over accountability
In what can only be described as a shocking display, Marvin Gonzales disrespected then PM & Political Leader Dr. Keith Rowley at the Tobago retreat — an act that stunned many. Who is Marvin to raise his voice in violent retort at a man with over 36 years of unbroken public service to party and country? Who is Marvin to demand Dr Rowley "leave and go now, we fed up of you" As we heard from the conclaves of the freeport mansions, this freshman so unworthy likened to a forced-ripe sapodilla -looking sweet on the outside but still hard and scratchy inside, took himself way to serious in Tobago.
2. A manufactured rise, not a movement leader
Gonzales has no organic history in the party, never tested, never tried, just glamorized. No time in the Youth League. No role in the constituency groups. He entered via Colm Imbert’s backdoor, styled himself as a reformer, and now seeks to chair a party he barely understands, knows, served or even respected. He's had zero years of community and social service, not even in a village council, friendly society or legal advisor to the Syrian-Lebanese Women's Association. "The strength of the Party lies in the character, ability, and devotion of its members." – Dr. Eric Williams.
3. Five years, one ministry, no delivery
He had five years to transform WASA. Instead, we got endless press briefings, catfights, with zero results, and a collapsing public utility sector. He ignored T&TEC, SWMCOL, TTPOST and other agencies. He crushed the morale of everyday workers. But worse, Gonzales has become the poster child of enriching UNC-aligned contractors while using a political sledgehammer against small working-class WASA employees, many of whom are children of long-standing PNM members. He made enemies of our own. He turned off T&TEC and WASA workers, both PSA and OWTU, sending them into the arms of the UNC.
4. The ‘One PNM’ hoax
This slate he now fronts as candidate Chairman — dubbed One PNM — is anything but united. It is a stitched-together alliance of ambition. Behind it? The long arm of Colm Imbert, now curiously rebranding himself as Penny Beckles’ charmed advisor. Word on the ground? He's quietly boasting that he, not Penny, is the de facto Opposition Leader, with her just holding the title. It is time to speak plainly. Colm Imbert has become the shadowy hand behind too many recent missteps. From undermining Dr. Rowley to propping up Penny Beckles and inserting his influence through Rhoda Bharath, Farai Massasai, and Marvin Gonzales — this is not “One PNM.” This is One Plantation Politics. Let’s be clear: This is not about race — it is about power. And the longer we remain silent, the more we allow backroom brokers to treat the party as a private club. "This party does not belong to any one man, clique, or interest group. It belongs to the people of Trinidad and Tobago." – Dr. Eric Williams.
5. A divisive figure, not a unifier
Party groups across the country say the same thing: Marvin doesn’t call back, doesn't answer his phone, and neither responds to WhatsApp. Doesn’t check in. Doesn’t build. Only does UPICK breakfast Saturdays with his contractor friends like Fides Ltd of EMBD fame. From WASA to the party faithful — his silence is loud. He is not the candidate to bring people together. He is the candidate to drive them apart. Anyone listening to him on Saturday night in Angel Harps wondered where he lived and which party he belonged to. The very leaders he criticized many sat on the platform, and the audience applauded. Out of the abundance of ambiguity, the PNM Leadership members present on One-Team - Colm Imbert (Ag. PM, Former Chairman & Dep. PL, currently illegally elected Vice Chairman), Nyan Gadsby-Dolly ( former Dep. PL, currently illegally elected Chairman), Foster Cummings (Gen Sec), others on the national executive, Indar Parasram (Elections Officer), Irene Hinds (Operations Officer), Faris Al Rawi (PRO), and Patricia Alexs (Assistant Gen Sec). So we ask. Who are these members on the National Executive you refer to, Marvin Gonzales? Do you process things differently or have a unique way of seeing the world? This is the very way he has characterized WASA workers over the last 5 years. Although he markets himself as youthful, Gonzales is widely seen as politically manufactured by insiders whose influence has alienated the base. A vote for him is a vote to entrench the very system the public just rejected. His candidacy is polarizing. His name does not inspire consensus or cohesion across regions or leagues. He lacks the temperament and trust to build unity across the party's generational and ideological divides.
The verdict
Marvin Gonzales may be a brilliant legal mind, but he does not have the heart, history, or humility to lead this party as chairman. He has mistaken self-promotion for political service. And Penny Beckles, if she truly believes he is the best to lead us, is as deceived as he is vain.
The PNM needs healing, not high drama.
We need leadership, not legacy manipulation.
What about Farai?
Farai Hove Masasai is an intelligent, articulate, and committed young lawyer with promise, but he is politically unprepared, and as such, he is not ready. Worse, he is being pulled by two troubling forces: Foster Cummings and Colm Imbert. Until he disentangles himself from that web, his promise remains premature. To do otherwise is a dangerous combination for a party crying out for independence, maturity, and unity.
Chinua Alleyne: grounded, humble, ready
Chinua has served this party at every level — Party Group, Youth Officer, Constituency Executive, General Council now Mayor of Port of Spain.
He has walked with the base. Listened to the elders. Led without fanfare.
He has no mentors pulling strings, only the lessons of Patrick Manning and the writings of Dr Eric Williams. No backroom brokers writing his speeches.
He is his own man — and more importantly, he is our kind of leader.
Visible and present: Chinua has been walking with party groups, supporting youth leagues, and maintaining presence in the communities before, during, and after elections.
Trusted and respected: He is one of the few leaders who has maintained respect from both senior party elders and emerging youth leaders. He listens. He learns. He leads with humility.
Competent and calm: An academic. A ground soldier. He knows the weight of service. From his own hard work and entrepreneurship projects to steering Port of Spain with dignity and discipline. As Mayor of Port of Spain, Alleyne has managed the capital city through multiple challenges without drama, scandal, or spectacle — but with solid, consistent leadership.
Visionary and bold: He understands that the party must modernize, decentralize power, and strengthen its internal democracy. His candidacy is built on reform, inclusion, and reconnection.
Political reality check: global & local context
Across the globe, we see examples where parties that refuse to self-correct are punished:
UK Conservative Party (2024): Voter backlash over elitism and disconnection from grassroots.
Democratic Party (USA): Younger, more grounded candidates are gaining traction over establishment picks. (Penny's One-PNM slate) MUST BE REJECTED
A factual, analytical summary of Marvin Gonzales' performance in Arouca/Lopinot during the 2025 general election, with context about his political vulnerabilities as a first-term MP, tells the following story;
Election Results – Arouca/Lopinot (2025)
Marvin Gonzales (PNM): 7,961 votes
Natalie Chaitram-Maharaj (UNC): 7,699 votes
Margin of victory: Only 262 votes
Total electorate: 28,493
Votes cast (major candidates only): 15,898 (≈56% voter turnout)
Changemakers analysis
1. Marginal win in a historically safe PNM seat
Arouca/Lopinot has long been considered a PNM stronghold. Yet, in 2025, Gonzales scraped by with a margin of just 262 votes. This razor-thin result highlights a major erosion in base support, signaling discontent with his leadership or public engagement over the last five years.
2. Poor incumbent performance
As the sitting Minister of Public Utilities, Gonzales had significant national visibility and control over key service-delivery portfolios (e.g., WASA, T&TEC). His narrow win suggests that many voters, including traditional PNM supporters, felt disappointed or disillusioned by his performance.
3. Low voter mobilization
Despite being an incumbent and a minister, Gonzales failed to energize voters. Out of nearly 28,500 eligible voters, fewer than 8,000 voted for him. This reflects:
Weak ground game and community presence.
Inadequate response to local concerns (e.g., water, infrastructure).
Potential backlash from controversies involving his approach to public servants and communities.
4. Backlash from the internal party base
Gonzales' national rhetoric around WASA reform, union friction, and allegations of corruption may have alienated traditional PNM loyalists—including workers, contractors, and families tied to public institutions. His tone has often been seen as technocratic and confrontational, not grounded in party-building or grassroots empathy.
Scenario: all opposition votes go to UNC
If UNC + NTA + PF votes consolidated:
Total opposition = 7,699 (UNC) + 746 (NTA) + 538 (PF) = 8,983
Compare with Gonzales’ 7,961 votes:
Opposition unified total: 8,983
Gonzales PNM total: 7,961
Margin of loss (hypothetical): 1,022 votes
Conclusion: YES, Marvin would have lost
If the UNC, NTA, and PF votes had consolidated under a single opposition candidate, Marvin Gonzales would have lost Arouca/Lopinot by over 1,000 votes.
This reinforces his political vulnerability and questions his suitability to lead as Chairman of the PNM:
He only survived due to opposition fragmentation.
His seat is now objectively marginal, not safe.
As a leader, he cannot expand beyond the PNM base or defend party territory under pressure.
His constituency support is very weak as he barely retained seat in a traditional PNM base.
Fragile public appeal given his failure to maintain or grow voter loyalty despite having a national Ministry and profile.
His political style remains one that is perceived as aloof, reactive and disconnected from both community and PNM base.
His leadership readiness clearly shows no evidence of coalition-building or party-ground nurturing.
The path forward
PNM members, we must think soberly.
Marvin Gonzales is not a mistake — he is a warning.
This election is not about who looks polished or speaks well on a platform. It's about who knows our pain, shares our story, eats "macaroni pie" with us and can restore our pride.
Chinua Alleyne is that leader.
Final word from the PNM Changemakers
Ask yourself: Where did Marvin come from? And where can he take us? “If we get this choice wrong, we risk losing not just the next election, but the next generation of PNM supporters.”
The answer is clear.
Reject illusion.
Reject manipulation.
Reject entitlement.
Vote Chinua Alleyne. Rebuild the PNM. Start now.
#ReclaimThePNM #VoteChinua #NoMoreIllusions
— PNM Changemakers 2025